The oyster pan roast and the lobster roll are two dishes that need to die. Both used to be poor men’s suppers; both are now willful and wasteful anachronisms. Luxury ingredients need to be showcased not hidden. And luxury ingredients gone bad or borderline need to be discarded not disguised.
Such is the case with Grand Central Oyster Bar’s overhyped oleaginous oyster stew. Their version is all cream, potato, paprika and bivalves on the edge of e.coli overload. It tastes less of the sea than the sewer, as do the restaurant’s raw offerings on the bookends to the workweek.
For its part, Lobster Roll’s (1980 Montauk Highway E.) version of its namesake dish is undeniably safe and inoffensive but also inexcusably bland. First do no harm, sure, but then don’t bore me either. In any case, neither restaurant is more than a road or rail side distraction in its current form, and neither dish merits the time or money.
If you are going to stake your name on a single dish at least do what you do right, as Rebecca Charles does at the West Village’s Pearl Oyster Bar. Unfortunately, rather than putting me in mind of the superior bread, texture and flavor intensity of her lobster roll, or her oysters for that matter, this Amagansett offering had me reminiscing about the Rt. 9 Westborough McDonald’s seasonal lobster roll. A lesser road and a lesser restaurant on paper but not on the plate.
In both places, the lobster tasted of nothing, the celery in the salad hid what little flavor was in the meat, and the roll was unbuttered and uninteresting. That said, McDonald’s has much better fries and much lower prices, coupled with much better managed customer expectations.
Yes, Lobster Roll does offer a sense of place. Blond servers of surprisingly diverse ages—prom queens past and present—speak to a long history in a single locale, and Capt. Jack kitsch décor is a pleasant reminder of old seafood shacks everywhere from Ann Arbor to Anna Maria. Also, the celebrity endorsement page of the menu is endearingly outdated: “newlyweds Kim Basinger and Alec Baldwin” and seventies heavy—Cheryl Tiegs to Peter Boyle. And that’s about as good as it gets.
Conclusions: Next time you’re on the Montauk Highway, engage in some Emersonian self-reliance, and hit a roadside fish shop for whatever’s fresh. Grill it up at your rental, house, or one of the nearby parks (Hither Hills, for instance) and call it a day. There’s no reason to get off the road for this one.